« Pornographers Love Me | Main | Babes in Warland »

Freedom and Liberty

An awful lot of the sci-fi fans are also libertarians, so they naturally enough are eager to smoke out the awesomely libertarian themes in Firefly and Serenity. The movie unquestionably makes an anti-paternalist point. On the other hand, the specific act of government-sponsored paternalism is question is so grandiose that I don't really think it does a great deal to cut against people who favor, say, a paternalistic tax on junk food. SPOILERS.

I mean, obviously, "avoid paternalistic schemes that feature massive downside risk unless you're really, really certain your scheme will work" is a sound principle of political action, but to term it a specifically libertarian principle is to cast a rather wide net. On the other hand, I think the Firefly theme song lyrics capture something important about the general theme of the show:

Take my love, take my land
Take me where I cannot stand
I don't care, I'm still free
You can't take the sky from me
Take me out to the black
Tell them I ain't comin' back
Burn the land and boil the sea
You can't take the sky from me
There's no place I can be
Since I found Serenity
But you can't take the sky from me...
This is unquestionably a show (and a song) about freedom but I don't think it has a huge connection to political liberty. What's the distinction? Well, there's a clear sense in which I enjoy more freedom in my life than does a typical married-with-kids middle aged bank assistant manager living in Concord, New Hampshire. But that sort of freedom doesn't follow from the notion that I enjoy more political liberties than does said bank manager. Indeed, I probably have somewhat less in light of the District of Columbia's relatively strict tax-and-regulatory environment vis-a-vis New Hampshire. I'm just not particularly tied down by anything, my job offers me a like of flexibility in terms of hours, my boss is quite relaxed about demeanor, etc., etc. The crew of Serenity -- and Mal Reynolds in particular -- are clearly people who value the kind of freedom I enjoy. Reynolds has a lot of autonomy. He gets to "do his own thing" and make his own rules. He's got an anti-authoritarian personality. But that's not the same as saying he places an especially high value on basic political liberties, especially not the sort of controversial political liberties that divide libertarians from other people in the American political context.

September 27, 2005 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8345160fd69e200d83458ef8453ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Freedom and Liberty:

Comments

Well I suppose it is libertarian in the sense that there's a sense that libertarian politics are conductive to creating personalities like Malcolm Reynolds. I mean, it's hard to imagine a DC journalist or a NH banker singing(in earnest, at least) about how you can't take the sky from them, but it's more plausible with a space smuggler. Something along the lines of John Holbo's review of Dead Right

Anyway, I'm not so sure about the advocacy of libertarian policies either. To the extent you can draw this kind of conclusions from made up stories, "Hear of Gold(briefly: the local thug and his heavily armed militia try to take away a prostitute's and the thug's baby from the prostitute, Malcolm helps the prostitute, but lots of people, including good guys, are killed in the process) should make ou very skeptical about law enforcement by an armed citizenry.

Posted by: WhichFerdinand | Sep 27, 2005 10:57:07 PM

Yeah, but who built his fucking spaceship? Did the workers who bolted it together have a safe working environment? Did they get paid as they were promised? Who enforced their rights?

I think SF is a great place for libertarian fantasies -- because that's all they'll ever be, just fantasies. If you want a stateless paradise, just move to Baghdad.

Posted by: c. | Sep 27, 2005 11:22:19 PM

I don't see any spoilers here, unless the distinction between freedom and liberty is hashed out in the final scenes of the movie.

Posted by: djw | Sep 28, 2005 12:07:52 AM

In defense of libertarians, Baghdad has lots of statist violence, courtesy of [future] U.S. taxpayers. Somalia is a more reasonable libertarian paradise (interestingly, things are bad in Somalia, but arguably they're better than they were under Barre.)

Matt, have you read Nomy Arpaly's _Unprincipled Virtue_? She has a section on "varieties of autonomy" that I think is rather interesting. I think that well informed libertarians are already privy to the distinctions between normative autonomy, agent autonomy, personal efficacy, heroic autonomy, and psychological independence (even if they don't use Arpaly's language), but it's still a good book.

Posted by: Julian Elson | Sep 28, 2005 12:37:56 AM

Note: I don't mean to imply Baghdad would be peaceful without the U.S. (though it WOULD be peaceful -- if hideously repressive and brutal -- if we hadn't gone in in the first place). I just mean that STATE violence, as opposed to violence by various non-state actors, is common (you can make the case that it is necessary, though it seems, over the course of our 2.5 year experience there, that we've done more harm than good). If we withdrew and cut of the Iraqi government from aid, then maybe it'd be more of an anarcho-libertarian's dream.

Posted by: Julian Elson | Sep 28, 2005 1:00:14 AM

I disagree that Mal is interested in the type of autonomy you are describing. Consider the following two choices:

1. A 9-5 Monday-Friday job on a central planet

2. Scraping together a living as a farmer on a desolate world. The world is so harsh and unforgiving that one MUST wake up at 5am 7 days a week, work until 9pm, or DIE of starvation.

I think Mal would prefer option 2; he'd have less "free time" and day-to-day options once there, but he'd be on his own - making his own destiny - not a pawn of the system."...never have to be under the heel of nobody ever again." -Out of Gas

In a sense he HAS chosen a hard, hand-to-mouth existence scraping by as a smuggler, rather than apply his talents to becoming a normal citizen of the Alliance, where he could live a comfortable, but controlled, life.

Also, if Mal chose the smuggler's life to be about to, as you put it, "do his own thing," then he's clearly irrational. Mal is oftentimes forced BY CIRCUMSTANCES to follow one narrow course of action (take any job available, no matter how shady; try to sell stolen cargo to a person who shot him.) The key thing is that being forced by circumstances to do something is regretable. But being forced to do something because of the whims of other people is unacceptable to Mal.

Posted by: wml | Sep 28, 2005 1:09:34 AM

Some people find libertarian themes in everything from Bad Boys II to Batman Begins, which can be irritating. But I think those themes are pretty hard to miss in Serenity. There's the "Virtual Public School" scene right at the beginning with River, where the kids and the teacher have a little colloquy about "why would anyone want independence. We give them technology and health care," and River says something about "we've meddled too much" with their lives.

Then in the rally-the-troops scene before the trip to Miranda, Mal gives his reason for going to war with the Alliance, and they're hilariously, obviously libertarian. The reason the Alliance is evil, per Mal? "They believe you can make people better."

Posted by: Gene | Sep 28, 2005 7:59:40 AM

Matt is obviously more adept at the philospohy behind this stuff, but it seems to me that their are too diametrically opposed libertarian arguments for samller goverment.
1) Government is inefficient (consequentialist)
2) Any taking of rights is wrong (deontological)

The implications of the first are that, if it could be shown that the government intervetion was more efficient than viable alternatives, it would be preferrable. Otherwise the argument means nothing.
The second, should be wholly unconcerned with whether or not it is more or less efficient.

The first, or any relative weighting of 2) [freedom is an important principle and we must give it weight when considering the efficiency of government interaction) is just a variant of liberalism with more emphasis on the relative importance of political freedom or the baseline assumptions of how efficient government can be (this is what I think most libertarians actually are, but sometimes confuse themselves into thinking 1))

Posted by: theCoach | Sep 28, 2005 10:51:41 AM

The spoiler would be that the movie hinges on a large government project gone horribly wrong. Which eh, I have friends who would bitch me out for saying that.

I think Matt understands there's a lot of work already in the distinction, and that Mal may even be a true libertarian. But the only message the movie manages to send to the audience is that personal freedom is good, and doesn't succeed too much in saying taxes are bad. Ie, if this movie got widespread cultural following, it would be more likely to make more cowboys than it would be to elect pro-choice anti-tax politicians.

Which is hardly surprising. One of the reasons that libertarianism is one of the political doctrines you can safely endorse in entertainment is because no one takes it seriously. Everyone thinks they're libertarian - until it comes up against a policy they want to implement. A lot of righteous Democrats will watch the movie without thinking about what it says about gas-taxes, or righteous Republicans will watch it without thinking what it says about Baghdad.

Posted by: Tony Vila | Sep 28, 2005 11:51:29 AM

There is a utilitarian way of looking at freedom that somehow confuses freedom with the "freedom" to have pleasure or happiness, but that doesn't seem to get at the point. It seems that the freedom that Mal and his crew are seeking, and the freedom the independents were fighting for, is the freedom to determine their lives in anyway that they saw fit. This is different fromt he "freedom" to have a easy job, or the "freedom" to have good working conditions or whatever. This freedom is not about ends but about process.
Also, The most Libertarian theme in Serenity seems to be the critique of the "improvers of mankind", the characters that are represented by the alliance. This is what should strike at the heart of any leftist project, becasue almost all of those projects are some attempt to remake humanity or the world into their image of heaven. This led to the settlers on Miranda being remade (for their own benefit) so that they would not be violent and this is the motivation of the cruelly amoral operative who could be quoting from Mao's little red book at certain points. It is the desire, in bizzare language, to "Immanentize the Eschaton" or bring heaven down to earth. This is what created the problems in the movie and this is the desire that has created the mass graves in China, Russia, and other places throughout the twentieth century. So, maybe it is not a libertarian movie, but it is certainly an anti-leftist movie.

Posted by: John | Sep 28, 2005 1:26:25 PM

I'm mostly serious when I say that we shouldn't pick on libertarians for embracing the virtual constructs of fiction (and yeah, a lot of it's sci fi) as proof that their ideas could work. For one thing, it makes for some great fiction. For another, it's better than the other places they get their ideas. Although now that I think about it, most of the best-run governments in fiction are monarchies. You know--Gondor, post-Wizard Oz, Naboo....

Scratch a libertarian, and he'll sue you in branches of government you didn't know existed.

Posted by: a different Matt | Sep 29, 2005 2:24:17 AM

You lost out by not going to that obscure tech school near Harvard, Matt. Every engineering campus I've ever been around has a coven of Heinlein-reading, Rush (the band) listening Randroids. In 2000, I got an evening's yux out of reading Libertarian political candidate webpages and seeing how many referred to Kirk at some point. I'm not joking.

I think the major reason for this (in particular because Rand's work is a how-to guide for bad engineering) is because libertarianism is currently highly technophilic, and SF tends to adopt the political trends of the most techophilic viewpoint. In the 30's-50's, that started out with a more or less communist POV, and then shifted more right wing as time passed.

That said, there are some modern authors who explicitly right in rejection of that. Ian Banks has stated that his Culture books are at least partly a reaction to the highly libertopian mindset of a lot of space opera.

Posted by: Mike Collins | Sep 29, 2005 10:04:19 AM

TheCoach, your first libertarian argument for smaller government is incomplete. The belief isn't just that government is inefficient. If that were the case, then you'd be correct, a libertarian couldn't object to the size of a government that is efficient.

The belief of libertarians is that government not only is inefficient, but that it simply can't be more efficient at its current size. Government provides services that it doesn't need to provide, and those services come at a cost to the efficient provision of legitimate government services.

It's simply a recognition that the more roles government takes on, the less well it is able to perform each one.

Posted by: Brooke | Sep 29, 2005 4:10:10 PM

FYI, Max Barry's "Jennifer Government" is a very entertaining send-up of libertarian utopias. I highly recommend it.

Posted by: Mike | Sep 30, 2005 10:32:36 AM

Brooke,
It is still an empiricle question, rather than a moral one. They can have the consequentialist reasoning, but then are bound by the evidence, or they can assert beliefs about the nature of government based on rights or freedom, in which case efficiency is irrelevent.
They can also confuse the issue by conflating the arguments, and use which ever one is more convenient (this is something liberals, Democrats, conservatives, etc. do a lot, of course).

Beyond that, it should be clear that efficiency is a relative term.

Posted by: theCoach | Sep 30, 2005 11:50:22 AM

FWIW, Joss Whedon has said in interviews that he thinks of Mal as "if not a Republican, then certainly a libertarian, a smaller-government kind of guy."

Posted by: Julian Sanchez | Sep 30, 2005 7:33:57 PM

I don't think we know enough of Mal's backstory to know what his beliefs are or why.

There's a lovely subtle bit in the pilot: In the Serenity Battle scenes, Mal kisses the crucifix hanging around his neck and says something about God smiling on them. Then, on the ship Serenity, when Book offers to say grace, Mal says "[I won't mind] only if you say it out loud." Mal used to have faith; he lost it in the war. Maybe he lost a lot of things in the war, or in the process of deciding to fight the war.

I can see Mal thinking, once upon a time, that there wasn't anything particularly wrong with the Alliance - as the engine of commerce, of technology, medicine, etc. that keeps the 'verse running - as long as being part of the Alliance was a choice, and a person or a planet could choose non-affiliation; could choose, as Mal presumably did, to live outside of it. Once that choice was no longer possible, then he made the decision to rebel, and take up arms in that rebellion.

I loved the movie. I have a few minor quibbles here and there, but that's all. The one thing I kind of regret is that the plot involved such a momentous confrontation, with a hint of more momentous confrontations to come. And that's only because I don't see how it can go back now to some of the sweet silliness the TV series could indulge, like the dizzy-fun capers with shady women :)

Posted by: CaseyL | Oct 1, 2005 1:33:09 AM

For what it's worth, here's a relevant comment of Whedon's from an NYT interview done when Firefly first aired:

"''Mal's politics are very reactionary and 'Big government is bad' and 'Don't interfere with my life,''' Whedon explains. ''And sometimes he's wrong -- because sometimes the Alliance is America, this beautiful shining light of democracy. But sometimes the Alliance is America in Vietnam: we have a lot of petty politics, we are way out of our league and we have no right to control these people. And yet! Sometimes the Alliance is America in Nazi Germany. And Mal can't see that, because he was a Vietnamese.''

Posted by: tennin | Oct 2, 2005 5:47:17 PM

sexe homme pour femme video bijoux fimo homme costume de marie pour homme sexe gratuit homme photo vestiaire homme homme slip calvin homme gay flyer chemise ralph lauren homme petits sexe homme bijoux argent homme sex gay homme homme qui porte des collant les droit de l homme bafoue photo homme velus body slip homme sexy homme veste kaki homme femme cherche homme quebec declaration universelle droit homme preambule pull ras du cou homme vieille femme cherche jeune homme homme cherche femme seul soiree coquin sexe homme recherche femme sex veste homme coton
homme soumis cherche maitresse tee shirt homme grossiste homme docile soumis vente cosmetique homme sm recit homme soumis pantalon jeans diesel achat homme jeune homme poilu manteau street wear homme discrimination entre homme et femme homme soumis sm pantalon homme avec pince tee shirt direction taille homme muscle homme nu homme tee shirt recit homme soumis sexe dessin homme et femme tee shirt blanc homme recherche homme black sac bandouliere homme homme masque fer histoire couple cherche homme elle couple bi cherche homme bi agen galerie gratuite masturbation homme dolce gabbana shirt homme video mere avec jeune homme sac et baiseenville homme

Pornographic character information...

Posted by: Cronos | Feb 13, 2006 7:08:58 PM

rencontre des fille vierge icone de la vierge a l enfant vierge chatte personnalite signe de la vierge 100 cd vierge moins cher fete sainte vierge enveloppe papier vierge cd dvd vierge noire picabia sainte vierge verbatim 50 cd vierge club 8 medley 2003 live at totp 27.12.03 video carte grece antique vierge first time 18 first time sex video sexe live show gratuit first time in ass apparition vierge versailles gratuit video x video and porno video sexe gratis free porn video clip clip video musique gratuit video xxx demande paris hilton video sexe jeu video pc video xxx gratuite video x hard carte graphique sortie video video sexe free video porno gratuite sans telecharger jeu video porno carte video tuner tv xxx gratuit video gratuit video gratuite du net clip video sexy video lesbienne lecteur dvd divx portable video embarquee mystral dpx515 moteur recherche video x gratuite 194.146.227.8 amateur anna video video gratuite sexe amateur extrait gratuit de video gay video sex drole telechargement video x totalement gratuite video gag porno extrait video sex petite video drole camera video amateur

Posted by: Meduza | Feb 14, 2006 9:07:29 AM

restaurant enterrement de vie de garcon epreuve enterrement vie garcon garcon nu public vetement homme laurent cerrer evolution de l homme nu entre garcon vetement garcon 18 mois hommes nu garcon devenir fille homme femme nu bayard prud homme achat string homme ides offrire original cadeaux homme vetement homme tres grand photo celebrite homme nu string transparent homme sexe photo video gratuite extrait video mpeg sexe totalement gratuit video gratuite extrait sexe amateur video sexe gratuit visioner video sexe gratuit sexe video du jour video sexe amateur francaise video sexe zoophile gratuit clip video gratuit de sexe free video clip sexe gratuit gigas video de sexe gratuit sexe video photo gratuite sexe photo video gratuite mini video gratuite sexe extrait de video de sexe hard gratuit sexe and francais and gratuit and video sexe and extrait and free gratuit sexe avec extrait video video sexe acces gratuit video hard sexe gratuit free sexe video sexe gratuit video extrait amateur video sexe gratuit extrait video gratuit sexe amateur video entiere site amateur sexe video sexe porno gratuit video amateur sexe gratuit sexe extrait video amateur free video and sexe and allopass extrait gratuit clip video sexe video gratuit telecharger porno sexe film gratuit amateur lesbienne femme lesbienne gros sein nu lesbienne gode archive video lesbienne gratuit britney spears video nu lesbienne rencontre et annonces lesbienne extrait de video de lesbienne gratuite jeune lesbienne video gratuit gratuit chat lesbienne sex lesbian blond lesbian shower pussy of lesbian lesbian cute pussy femme lesbienne kiss escorte lesbian young orgasm lesbian asslick lesbian movie

Posted by: marck | Feb 15, 2006 11:08:56 AM

partage reseau logiciel logiciel web tv logiciel partage ecran telecharger logiciel partage fichier logiciel webcam creative vita plus accessoire organiseur logiciel gps pc logiciel music jetaudio logiciel telecharger clip video music gratuit protection logiciel mac logiciel dvd lecture logiciel java microsoft vm telecharge logiciel emule logiciel mettre texte gif 3d logiciel solution association ciel logiciel emule plus logiciel gratuit creation diaporama travaux orthophoniques sur langue signe horoscope taureau langue signe fran�aise horoscope gratuit vierge 2005 didier colin horoscope 2006 signe cancer horoscope gratuit special 2006 horoscope novembre cancer loi sur signe religieux horoscope wanadoo fr ecole interpete langue signe signe astro vierge signe var horoscope personnalise horoscope chinois 2005 gratuit horoscope de l annee 2004 horoscope novembre balance signe zodiacal capricorne capricorne signe tous sur signe astrologique capricorne signe chinois amour astrologie signe ascendant signe astrologique compatibilites fond ecran signe astrologique scorpion signe astro signe avant coureur de grossesse

Posted by: Eddy | Feb 16, 2006 6:26:35 AM

fichier musique midi telecharger gratuitement musique sinik chanson francaise parole et musique lecteur chaine musique telecharger gratuitement et legalement musique midi files musique chanson franc gratuit telechargement legal musique gratuite musique zanzarah legende deux monde musique ceremonie mariage civil musique mp3 telecharger gratuitement ligne petite annonces cours musique marseille festival musique agrave saint victor top 30 musique cours musique havre musique top 20 algerien charger musique militaire
musique film ne nous fachons pas musique logiciel gratuit musique and gratuite and and telecharger and telecharger chanson and music telecharger ecouter musique harcore telecharger and musique telecharger musique sur portable telechargement de logiciel de musique gratuit musique telecharger gratuitement logiciel ecriture musique telecharger musique et film musique portable acheter de la musique a telecharger chanteur musique africaine france musique fr musique africaine ligne telechargement de clip musique gratuit musique clip amine article sur theorie musique arabe cd des musique dance 80 et 90 ecole normale musique france

Here we teach you how to discharge the best mp3 music as well as the last movies of Box Office.

Posted by: Baldur | Feb 16, 2006 5:54:34 PM

musique mariage gratuite karaoke chanson pierrot musique algerienne chanson de rap et rnb m6 chanson generique veux bebe bebe chanson midi mp3 telecharger vanbasco s karaoke les chanson chanson musique celine dion nouvelle chanson ecouter musique rif telechargement musique et film musique du film titanic logiciel de musique studio logiciel fabrication musique gratui galerie photo instrument de musique partition musique populaire dunkerque overnet telechargement gratuit musique musique film graver sur cd france 2 musique achat musique classique musique hard techno jungle musique free download clip musique cher song cd musique fete musique pub mp3 cd musique africaine musique africaine telecharger gratuitement musique armee francaise vangelis musique monde musique monde enfant musique monde cd creation musique rap festival musique du monde logiciel musique creation mp3 free downloading music transformer mp3 lecteur mp3 cle usb passer de wma a mp3 comparatif baladeur mp3 usb mp3 wma telechargement and musique and mp3 baladeur mp3 dictaphone juke box baladeur mp3 ipod encodeur mp3 freeware convertisseur mp3 a mp3 sandisk mp3 baladeur lecteur mp3 wingogo mp3 encoder easy mp3 converter convertir fichier wav fichier mp3 fichier wav mp3 encoder mp3 freeware lecteur mp3 baladeur hp telecharger musique video radio dance music sony music clip music arabic com illimite telecharger music mp3 legal sony stereo music systeme hmk 77b music maroc grauit clip music ucp video dbpoweramp music converter audio cd input radio city music hall histoire pop music ecouter musique arabe instrument music basse ecouter musique de walt disney ecouter and de and la and musique ecouter de la musique sur internet

Posted by: ladislao | Feb 17, 2006 5:57:14 AM

telecharger emule gratuit fr e donkey emule film fr canada probleme serveur avec emule film a telecharger avec emule mise and a and jour and serveur and emule telecharger emule v0.46c gratuitement lien direct emule film emule x lien forum adulte emule telechargement liens emule 0.45 serveur emule 0.46c emule inside projet configuration and emule and and and and z emule 0.44d gratuit aide and emule logiciel musique mac logiciel musique encore ou finale logiciel boutique en ligne logiciel coiffure et paie meilleur logiciel antivirus telecharger logiciel composer musique logiciel fiche paie musique logiciel logiciel telechargement des carte prepayee gsm logiciel paie freeware logiciel gestion paie calendrier logiciel de traduction francais japonais logiciel gestion de tresorerie logiciel dessin circuit imprime logiciel platine mixage logiciel de mixage professionnel

Posted by: Brower | Feb 20, 2006 8:09:44 AM

The comments to this entry are closed.